Same meal, different value
A guest orders the same meal through a delivery marketplace on Tuesday and through your own website on Friday. The kitchen makes it twice. The weekly sales report adds both to one orders number and one revenue number, and moves on.
That blended number hides the question a marketing plan actually needs answered: what does each ordering channel return? The marketplace order usually carries commissions and fees, sometimes a promo you funded, and rarely a guest contact you can market to. The order on your own site usually carries far fewer deductions and a guest you can reach again. Same meal, different value.
The fix is one small table, kept weekly. It's our practice framing, not a benchmark, so there are no industry rates below. The numbers that matter are yours.
The five columns, and where each comes from
One row per channel: your own website, your own app, each marketplace you're on, phone and walk-in if you track them. Five columns:
| Column | What it means | Where it comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Orders | Completed orders in the week | Marketplace payout statements; your ordering platform export; the POS |
| Gross sales | What guests paid for food, before deductions | Same sources |
| Channel costs | Commissions, fees and any promo cost the channel charged you | Marketplace payout statements; your ordering platform and payment fees for your own channels |
| Net after channel costs | Gross sales minus channel costs, then divided by orders for net per order | Calculated |
| Guest-contact share | Share of orders where you received a guest contact you are allowed to market to | Your ordering platform or CRM; usually near zero for marketplaces |
Use payout statements and your own exports, not ad dashboards. Ad platforms report the conversions they credited to themselves, which isn't the same as orders and says nothing about what each order cost to fulfill through its channel.
The last column is a reporting field, not legal guidance. Whether you're allowed to market to a contact depends on what the guest agreed to, and that's a question for your counsel.
Filling it weekly in under an hour
Once the exports are set up, the weekly routine is short:
- Download each marketplace's payout statement for the week.
- Export orders from your own ordering platform for the same days.
- Pull phone or walk-in counts from the POS if you include them.
- Paste the totals into the table, one row per channel, and let the net column calculate.
Statements don't always arrive on the same schedule. When a channel's statement lags, fill that row with last week's net per order as a placeholder, mark it clearly, and replace it when the statement lands. Don't skip the row. A table with a missing marketplace looks like that channel had no orders.
If stores are named differently in each export, this is the step that eats the hour. One Store, One Key fixes that once, so you can also run the table by store.
Reading the table
Three numbers do most of the work:
- Net per order by channel. The gap between your own channels and each marketplace is what a guest switching channels is worth to you.
- Guest-contact share. This is the long-term column. A channel that returns less per order but recruits guests you can reach again may still be worth growing.
- Order share. If a lower-net channel is growing as a share of orders, your average order is getting less valuable even if total sales look healthy.
None of this says marketplaces are bad. They reach guests a brand wouldn't reach on its own, and for some stores that reach is the point. The table makes the trade-off visible: reach on one side, margin and guest data on the other. Your Own Orders vs Marketplace Orders covers what each channel lets you measure.
To make the arithmetic concrete, here's an illustrative example only, not a typical rate: if one channel deducts a fifth of a $30 order and another deducts a twentieth, the first returns $24 and the second $28.50 for the same meal. Swap in your own numbers from your statements.
Where your media actually sends people
Once you know which channel you'd rather grow, check where your marketing points. List every "order now" destination you control:
- Paid search and social ads, and the landing pages behind them.
- The order buttons on your website, on every page type.
- Links on social profiles and in bios.
- Each location's business listing and its order link.
- Email and text campaigns.
It's common to find paid media sending guests to a marketplace listing while the brand wants own-site orders to grow. That's not a tracking problem, it's a destination choice nobody revisited. If paid campaigns are optimizing toward orders, also check that each order is counted once, and that catering orders are counted at all.
What to change first
- Report by channel. Split the weekly sales report into the five-column table, even if some cells start as estimates.
- Align campaign destinations with the channel you want to grow. Where a campaign has no reason to send guests to a marketplace, send them to your own ordering.
- Revisit monthly. Watch net per order and guest-contact share move as destinations change.
If you want help building reporting that ties channels, stores and campaigns together, book a data and tracking audit. If you also want to see what your restaurant site loads before a guest makes a privacy choice, request a free privacy scan. We review each request within 48 hours.
Rawsoft provides technical implementation and analysis, not legal advice. Please confirm any regulatory interpretation with your counsel.